Macall Polay7. Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere
Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere could have been this year’s answer to A Complete Unknown – a drama about a revered American singer-songwriter that focused on one key point in his career. Jeremy Allen White from The Bear put in the effort to sing and play like Bruce Springsteen, and the writer-director, Scott Cooper, had already made an Oscar-nominated film about an American singer-songwriter – albeit a fictional one – Crazy Heart (2009). Despite all that, audiences didn’t fancy watching a rock star moping around New Jersey, having a minor romance, and recording an album of quiet acoustic tracks in his bedroom. What they wanted was the surging energy and urgent storytelling that enliven so many of Springsteen’s stadium anthems. Deliver Me from Nowhere went nowhere. As refreshing as it may be when a biopic decides to home in on a small segment of its subject’s life, sometimes the whole “rags to riches / burn out / redemption” arc is what’s required.
Pixar8. Elio
Pixar’s Inside Out 2 was the biggest film in the world in 2024, so hopes were high for the studio’s next cartoon. Those hopes crashed down to earth when Elio was released in June. It wasn’t that the film was terrible, but it was fatally compromised. A science-fiction coming-of-age adventure, it was conceived as a personal story by Adrian Molina, the co-director of Coco, who was inspired by his own lonely childhood on a military base. But then, in 2024, Molina left the project, along with other key personnel, to be replaced by two different directors. The result was a cartoon that no longer had a compelling reason to exist; as with two other recent Disney flops, Strange World (2022) and Wish (2023), it was tricky to summarise the plot or to explain what was at stake. The film might have been better, it seems, if Molina had just been left to get on with it. Ultimately, the Disney alien that made a fortune this year was Stitch from Lilo & Stitch rather than any of the bug-eyed extra-terrestrials in Elio.
Universal Studios9. M3GAN 2.0
Why did M3GAN 2.0 malfunction? When M3GAN came out three years ago, it was a meme-spawning hit: the homicidal robot, with its long hair and cutesy dress, was clearly designed to become a Halloween costume, and a clip of the sinister Model 3 Generative Android’s dance routine went viral. All the director Gerard Johnstone had to do was deliver more of the same and he could have watched the money roll in. The glitch was that he decided not to deliver more of the same. While both films could be described as tongue-in-cheek science-fiction satires, M3GAN was a suburban slasher chiller, and the sequel was a sprawling, geopolitical action thriller. On its own terms, M3GAN 2.0 was terrific fun – but sometimes you have to give the people what they want. “We all thought M3GAN was like Superman. We could do anything to her,” the film’s producer, Jason Blum, said on The Town podcast. “We could change genres. We could put her in the summer. We could make her look different. We could turn her from a bad guy into a good guy. And we classically over-thought how powerful people’s engagement really was with her.”
A2410. The Smashing Machine
Dwayne Johnson has been one of the world’s biggest film stars for over a decade, literally and figuratively, but there comes a time when every commercial colossus wants to prove that he or she can cut it as a serious dramatic actor, too. And so it was that The Rock made his bid for an Oscar – or at least an Oscar nomination – by starring in The Smashing Machine. All the signs were promising, in that Johnson had a prestigious co-star (Emily Blunt), a feted director (Benny Safdie, who made Good Time and Uncut Gems with his brother Josh), and a true story about a mixed martial artist battling with addictions. The trouble was that Johnson wasn’t flexing many acting muscles that he hadn’t flexed before: he was a charismatic wrestler playing a charismatic wrestler. The only major difference from his previous work was that The Smashing Machine was depressing – and no one goes to see a film starring The Rock because they want to be depressed. Still, you can’t help feeling sorry for the director. His brother made another sports biopic, Marty Supreme, starring Timothée Chalamet – and it’s getting all the plaudits that didn’t go to The Smashing Machine.
—
If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can’t-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week.
For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.